
Why tokenized real-world assets rarely trade after issuance
WatchEpisode 2 · Ghost Town Markets: Building Secondary Liquidity for Real-World Assets
Protofire writes decentralized OTC contracts for tokenizers and issuers. Wallets you permit take offers on your own assets, and both legs settle in one transaction. In 2021 we built the DEX core and subgraph for Swarm Markets and contributed to its dOTC. You operate the venue and run KYC.

Reviewed by Luis Medeiros, Field CTO at ProtofireLast reviewed: November 2026
Work shipped for 60+ networks and 95+ protocols, including
A decentralized OTC contract handles block trades in a tokenized asset. One wallet posts an offer, another wallet takes it at the offer's price, and the contract settles both sides. For example, you issued a tokenized bond to verified investors. One of them now wants to sell a large block, and your head of treasury asks where that trade can happen.
Protofire writes decentralized OTC contracts for the asset, the access rules and the chain you run. Pooled trading is our DEX development work. The issuance platform behind the token is our tokenization infrastructure service.
The contracts reject a take from a wallet that the authorization contract does not approve. Your keys hold the owner, manager and escrow roles.
A token built to ERC-3643 refuses a transfer to a wallet that is not a verified identity.The standard says: "The receiver MUST be whitelisted on the Identity Registry and verified" (EIP-3643). So a public pool address cannot receive the token unless someone registers it.
Where a pool is allowed, a large order is visible before it settles. The ethereum.org docs describe how a searcher "will watch the mempool for large DEX trades" and trades ahead of and behind them (ethereum.org).
Pantera Capital's market data describes OTC secondary trading in whitelisted tokens as limited. Its State of Tokenization Q1 2026 report (May update) scores how assets transfer. The score for "Whitelist-gated transfers" reads "Limited OTC secondary" (Pantera).
For the illiquid assets, assets that are inherently illiquid off-chain, tokenizing them doesn't suddenly increase liquidity or demand for trading these assets.
In 2021 Protofire built the DEX core (a Balancer fork) and subgraph for Swarm Markets and contributed to its dOTC.Swarm Markets was a BaFin-licensed DEX at launch where only KYC-verified wallets trade. Swarm held the license and ran the KYC.
Both repositories from the Swarm Markets build are public. One is a fork of Balancer's core (swarm-markets-balancer-core, GPL-3.0). The other is a fork of Balancer's subgraph (swarm-markets-subgraph, MIT). Both were created on 25 February 2021, and their last pushes were in September and December 2021. The case study describes the build. A dOTC contract has to fit this kind of setting: a venue with a license and verified wallets.
Protofire maintains Solhint, our open-source Solidity linter, which has been downloaded 25M+ times from npm. Contracts of this kind are the code Solhint reads.
In Swarm's open dOTC v2, the maker's asset goes into an escrow contract when the maker makes the offer.A take then settles in one transaction. Protofire describes Swarm's design because the escrow decides who needs which role (open-dotc, Swarm's own repository).
An offer names the asset the maker deposits and the asset the maker wants. It also names a price, an expiry and, optionally, the wallets allowed to take it. A taker names an offer, and the contract does the rest. In the same function, the taker's payment goes to the maker and the escrow releases the maker's asset to the taker. If either step fails, both revert. There is no AMM pool, no pricing curve and no matching engine. Swarm's documentation adds that the maker chooses partial or all-or-nothing takes (Swarm docs).
The dOTC contract checks access offer by offer. The maker can restrict an offer to named wallets or to wallets that an authorization contract approves. The authorization contract needs one function, isAccountAuthorized, and your KYC provider or your own registry answers it (KYC Select).
The escrow holds the deposits of all open offers, so its owner and manager roles matter. In Swarm's v2, the owner of the manager contract can change the fees and the dotc and escrow addresses. PeckShield's audit report of 18 January 2025 lists this power as a medium finding, PVE-004, "Trust Issue of Admin Keys", and marks it mitigated. In the build Protofire writes for you, you hold those roles.
Holders trade a large position at an agreed price without a pool in between. Protofire writes offer, take and cancel contracts for your tokens. Swarm documents its dOTC for ERC-20, ERC-721 and ERC-1155 assets.
You decide who may take an offer: named wallets, an authorization contract, or both. Protofire writes the authorization hook and connects it to your registry, or to your KYC provider through our compliance integration work.
An offer can have a fixed price, or a price set from a reference feed inside a band you choose. Dynamic prices are available where a feed exists for the asset. Protofire connects that feed through our oracle integration work.
These roles go to your addresses. Your engineer runs the launch scripts with your key. Protofire hands over the access configuration and the documentation with the scripts.
The front end lists open offers and lets permitted wallets take them. An indexer that you can host runs behind the page. Protofire builds the subgraph and the page for your assets.
The EU and US texts define a regulated trading venue by what its system does.
In the EU, a multilateral trading facility is a multilateral system that an investment firm or a market operator operates (MiFID II, Article 4(1)(22)). Such a system brings together multiple third-party buying and selling interests in financial instruments. It does so in the system and in accordance with non-discretionary rules, in a way that results in a contract. Each Member State must require prior authorization for investment services provided as a regular occupation or business on a professional basis (Article 5(1)).
For crypto-assets, operating a trading platform means managing one or more multilateral systems (MiCA, Article 3(1)(18)). These systems bring together, or facilitate the bringing together of, multiple third-party purchasing and selling interests in crypto-assets. They do so in the system and in accordance with its rules, in a way that results in a contract. A person may provide crypto-asset services in the Union only if it is authorized or is a regulated institution that MiCA lists (Article 59(1)).
In the US, a federal rule sets two conditions (17 CFR 240.3b-16(a)). A group of persons that meets both is treated as providing "a market place or facilities for bringing together purchasers and sellers of securities". First, the group brings together the orders for securities of multiple buyers and sellers. Second, it uses established, non-discretionary methods under which those orders interact and the buyers and sellers agree to the terms of a trade.
Whether a particular offer board is such a system depends on its design and on who operates it. The operator decides that question with its counsel and its regulator before launch.
A Protofire dOTC build starts from your token and your access rule.It ends with launch scripts that your engineer runs.
Work with Protofire starts when you send your token and chain and the access rule you want.You also name the firm that will operate the venue and run KYC. Each rule becomes a check in the authorization hook or a role in the launch scripts. Our how we work page describes the full process.
How we work shows a worked proposal.
A dOTC build that starts from Swarm's published code needs a license check first.In Swarm's open-dotc repository, DotcV2.sol, DotcEscrowV2.sol and DotcManagerV2.sol each include the notice SPDX-License-Identifier: GPL-3.0-only. The repository has no license file at its root. A Protofire build for you consists of contracts written for your assets and rules. If the build starts from Swarm's published dOTC code, your counsel clears the license before the work starts, because GPL-3.0 is a copyleft license.
Three kinds of buyer need something other than a dOTC build from Protofire.
In 2021 Protofire built the DEX core and subgraph for Swarm Markets and contributed to its dOTC contracts. Swarm Markets was a BaFin-licensed DEX at launch where only KYC-verified wallets trade. Swarm held the license and ran KYC and permissioning.

WatchEpisode 2 · Ghost Town Markets: Building Secondary Liquidity for Real-World Assets
Tell us what you are building. An engineer reads it, we have a short call, and the written proposal follows within one business day.